Energy Orb – Hacking Your Perception
The energy orb is a simple globular light that changes color depending on how much energy you are using, or how much energy is available.
On NPR Bob Garfield had an interview with Clive Thompson of Wired Magazine.
Here is a transcript of On the Media:
BOB GARFIELD: Environmental responsibility is an issue on everybody’s radar these days, and this month in Wired Magazine, Clive Thompson describes a new way for energy consumers to be aware of their consumption. It is an orb. It is awesome. Clive [LAUGHS], welcome back.
CLIVE THOMPSON: Good to be here.
BOB GARFIELD: Now, this is about ambient technology. Tell me what that means.
CLIVE THOMPSON: Well, ambient technology is a way of delivering information in a more calming way. The idea arose about 10 years ago in response to the fact that computers, particularly computers, were becoming much more stressful because they had so many sources of information that they’re forcing you to stare at. There’s email and there’s browsers, and now there’s YouTube and all this stuff. And so people were getting sort of drowned in all the information that they had to stare at.
And the idea was, well, maybe we should try and take some information and just sort of put it in the periphery of your eye span, as it were, you know, so that something you sort of glance at every once in a while, you don’t have to stare at it.
BOB GARFIELD: Like a wall clock or a thermometer?
CLIVE THOMPSON: Precisely. A wall clock is a classic piece of ambient information, because even though you’re not really aware of ever looking at it, you always generally know what time it is. And so it’s a non-stressful source of information.
And it turns out that when they do studies, they find that ambient information, people actually retain it, sometimes even better than they do the stuff that they’re staring at.
BOB GARFIELD: Now comes the orb, which is a new medium. Tell me about the history of the orb and then we can talk about this current application.
CLIVE THOMPSON: Well, the orb is the invention of a guy named David Rose. He’s got a company called Ambient Devices. And his idea was okay, let’s try taking the important information off the computer screen and into the periphery of your attention. And he wanted a little, beautiful thing that would be sort of pleasant to have sitting in the corner of your desk. And so he thought of a glowing orb.
And his first application, and everyone loved this, was that you would set it to monitor [LAUGHING] your stock portfolio so that it would glow green or whatever if – and you could pick the color – it would glow green if things were going well and sort of it would slowly darken to purple or whatever if your stock portfolio was going down, and so the idea being that you would sort of generally know whether or not your financial health was being taken care of without having to go to E*Trade, you know, five times a day or whatever and look at your portfolio.
And it really worked. It turned out when they did studies they found that people were about – like I’m sketchy on the exact amount – but it was around like 30 or 40 percent more likely to do active trading, you know, once every month or so, if they had an orb because they could see, wait a minute, something’s wrong with my portfolio.
BOB GARFIELD: It’s a way to synthesize a lot of information just with a color spectrum.
CLIVE THOMPSON: Yeah, exactly.
BOB GARFIELD: So how did the orb come to be embraced for energy consumption?
CLIVE THOMPSON: What happened was that an engineer at a Californian energy firm decided to see if he could hack people’s perceptions to make them a little more aware of their energy usage by using orbs. And what he did was he basically bought about a thousand of these orbs and put them in people’s houses and configured them so that they would glow different colors based on whether or not the grid was being really stressed.
If it was really being overused, at total capacity, you know, it would glow red or whatever, and if the grid was actually not being used, it would glow green or whatever, and the idea being that people would sort of have a sense of what the energy environment around them is like and they would react accordingly. They would turn things off when energy was getting overstressed and too expensive, and they would save themselves money, and they would save, you know, their energy usage for when it was, you know, glowing green and things were less stressed.
And sure enough, the same thing happened. People actually very effortlessly started changing their energy usage habits and they actually, they conserved a lot more energy because they had – suddenly they had information on what was going on around them.
BOB GARFIELD: Now, in your piece in Wired, you actually wrote about a second stage of awareness, and that is when your awareness isn’t a closely-held secret but your own energy consumption is made available to a larger audience. Tell me how that works.
CLIVE THOMPSON: It’s called the sentinel effect. If you let other people know what you’re doing, their scrutiny will sort of freak out you out and you’ll try and do better, as it were.
So if everyone were able to – imagine like a word where, like, I’ve got my energy orb or whatever, and it broadcasts, you know, through my blog or my website to all my friends, Clive’s energy usage over the last week was, you know, up 20 percent or down 10 percent. You can sort of imagine this would very quickly take on, like, almost like a social virus type of effect where people would be almost actively reducing even more of their energy usage so they won’t look like a complete energy glutton in front of their friends. You know, it would have a really wonderful social effect.
There’s already a little experiment like this happening. Over in Britain there’s this cool company that have created this thing called the Watson, and it’s sort of like a little glowing brick. It does the same thing as the orb. It glows different colors based on your energy usage.
But the really cool thing is it’s networked to the Internet, so it feeds that information online, if you want it to, and you can go online and you can see, you can compare yourself with other Watson users and see who’s reduced the most energy.
And the other cool thing is you can see sort of how much in total all the Watson users have saved. That to me is really interesting, because one of the problems with personal conservation is that it feels like it’s just a drop in the bucket. Like why am I bothering to turn off this light? It’s not going to do anything.
Whereas, if you could go online and see that a million people had all turned off a light and you just saved [LAUGHING] 100 megawatts or the equivalent of 24 hours functioning of one coal-fired plant, that would really start to feel much more exciting and you’d be more likely to turn off that light.
BOB GARFIELD: Way cool. Clive, thank you so much for joining us.
CLIVE THOMPSON: Glad to be here.

August 28th, 2007 at 11:27 pm
Imagine if every house had a Watson or Orb mounted on the outside that showed the neighbours what you were up to energy wise. Sure you drive around in a Prius but nobody sees your 30minute shower or the fact that you love the effect of the 15 halogen spotlights that illuminate your living room. I truly believe that if doing the right thing environmentally remains a voluntary act – and people remain free to do as they please in the privacy of their own homes energy wise, that we are doomed. Maybe embarrassment is the only thing powerful enough to actually motivate the masses.
August 30th, 2007 at 11:40 am
It’s amazing how the human reacts when he/she knows that he/she can change a behaviour and make a difference. The wattson device from diykyoto is an excellent device and an exciting new way of raising awareness of energy consumption. I am aware of the smartmeter in the US, but I was wondering if anyone has any other information of orb-like devices.
August 30th, 2007 at 9:20 pm
Brian-
I disagree. I have a bit less of the Orwell in me. But I do think if everyone had a big LED meter in their kitchens that showed what their burn rate was as expressed in $/year you would see some pretty big changes overnight.
August 30th, 2007 at 9:26 pm
Jonathan-
The Wattson meter is pretty cool. Our library has a simpler device you can check out so you can see how much power your individual appliances are using.
The Wattson whole house (or business?) meter has the big LED display that I’ve always thought a house should have.
BTW – My cell phone charger doesn’t use a single watt when the phone isn’t connected.
Thanks for the comment!
August 31st, 2007 at 12:12 am
John, I sounded way too negative in my first post -it’s just hard not to feel hopeless at times. I guess what I was really saying was that the massive reduction in energy consumption I keep hearing we need, in order to save the planet from some very scary times, won’t happen without much stricter laws, more strict even than those currently proposed in California, and I know it can’t happen overnight. I don’t actually like the idea of more government interference in our lives but even with all the new inventions (Hybrids, LEDs, Solar, ect) it’s hard not to feel we are changing our energy sucking ways much too slowly – I can’t even believe how many new coal plants are on the table for India, China, and the USA – it’s in the 100s.
I totally agree that to motivate people to change their ways they need incentive, and I’ve rarely met a person who doesn’t want to save money, so it seems like the energy meter could be very effective. But I’m still guessing for an energy meter to really make a difference (Orwell or not) it would need to be mandatory (or really cheap) otherwise, you’d only have a few people buying one who were already concerned about energy consumption and had the extra money to fork out for another gadget.
April 16th, 2008 at 9:06 pm
[...] Link » Filed under Interaction Design by Mikko at 22:05. back to top [...]